Potential for Unintended  Legislative Changes
  

 Overview of Process

 Submitting Issues

 Panel Process

 Analysis

 Content/form of  submissions

 Outcomes and  Communication

 Penalties and Interest

 Disputes and Rulings  Processes

 


www.rewriteadvisory.govt.nz

FYI Issues Log Panel Statement Submission Form Issues Log Home Contact Us Background
 

  The Issues Log






















 
Issue: MB 4, KD 1(g)

Submission Number 97
Submitter McIntyre Dick & Partners

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 2007

MB 4

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 2004

KD 1(g)

Date Received

10/08/2008
Description of issue

An adjustment is required to be made to a taxpayers family scheme income for Working for Families Tax Credits if they are a major shareholder in a close company.  Under the 2004 Act this adjustment is calculated as the major shareholders voting interest in the company multiplied by the company\'s net income.  An amount equal to the dividends received by the taxpayer from the company is deducted.  However, under the 2007 Act there is no provision in the calculation to deduct the dividends received by the taxpayer from the company.

Give examples: A taxpayer holds 20% of the shares in a close company.  The company\'s net income for the year is $300,000.  The taxpayer received a dividend of $50,000 from the company in the same year.

Under the 2004 Act the taxpayer would be required to make an adjustment of $10,000 ((20% * 300,000)-50,000) to their net specified income for WFTC purposes.

Under the 2007 Act the taxpayer would be required to make an adjustment of $60,000 (300,000 * 20%) to their family scheme income for WFTC purposes.

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 1994

 

Status Finalised
Outcome The Panel concludes and agree an unintended legislative change arises in respect of section MB 4 of the Income Tax Act 2007.

The Income Tax Act 2007 be amended retrospectively.


Back

 
Home | Contact Us | Background | Issues Log | Submission Form | Panel Statement | Maintenance Items Log |
www.govt.nz
Potential for ULC Background Contact Us Home