Potential for Unintended  Legislative Changes
  

 Overview of Process

 Submitting Issues

 Panel Process

 Analysis

 Content/form of  submissions

 Outcomes and  Communication

 Penalties and Interest

 Disputes and Rulings  Processes

 


www.rewriteadvisory.govt.nz

FYI Issues Log Panel Statement Submission Form Issues Log Home Contact Us Background
 

  The Issues Log






















 
Issue: RD 3(3), RD 3(4), OB 2 2(d)

Submission Number 79
Submitter nsaTax Ltd

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 2007

RD 3(3) and RD 3(4)

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 2004

OB 2 2(d)

Date Received

25/07/08
Description of issue Section RD 3(3) and 3(4) of the 2007 Act refer to a person choosing whether an amount paid to them in the income year is or is not a payment of PAYE income. These sections refer to \"an amount\" paid to them. Section OB 2 of the 2004 Act at para 2(c) and 2(d) makes reference to all assessable income deerived in the tax year. The 2004 Act can be interpreted as meaning an \"all or nothing\" approach, i.e. if you elect to pay PAYE through the year then a year end bonus must also be at PAYE because OB 2(2)(d) refers to \"all assessable income\". However the 2007 Act indicates you could pay a salary and deduct PAYE throught the year and then a year end bonus (being an amount) could be credited with no PAYE deduction. Not an identified policy change so logic suggests that OB 2 should be followed however RD 3 wording suggests otherwise??
Section / Provision Income Tax Act 1994  
Status Finalised
Outcome The Panel has concluded and agree there is an unintended legislative change in respect of sections RD 3(3) and RD 3(4) of the Income Tax Act 2007.

That the Income Tax Act 2007 be amended prospectively from the next Income year.

Refer to Policy Advice Division for Policy review.


Back

 
Home | Contact Us | Background | Issues Log | Submission Form | Panel Statement | Maintenance Items Log |
www.govt.nz
Potential for ULC Background Contact Us Home