Potential for Unintended  Legislative Changes
  

 Overview of Process

 Submitting Issues

 Panel Process

 Analysis

 Content/form of  submissions

 Outcomes and  Communication

 Penalties and Interest

 Disputes and Rulings  Processes

 


www.rewriteadvisory.govt.nz

FYI Issues Log Panel Statement Submission Form Issues Log Home Contact Us Background
 

  The Issues Log






















 
Issue:  DU 12(3)(b), DN 3(3)(b)

Submission Number 69
Submitter nsaTax Ltd

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 2007

DU 12(3)(b)

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 2004

DU 12(3)(b)

Date Received

07/07/08
Description of issue

The submission relates to the section DN 3(3) (b) in the ITA 1994. That section allowed a deduction for the "aggregate amount" of exploration and development expenditure incurred "before the end of that year", (less all deductions allowed by the section in all tax years before the current one) .

However in the corresponding sections DU 12(3)(b) in the ITA 2004 and 2007, the section allows a deduction for "all " of the exploration and development expenditure incurred "in the tax year in which the amount is written off", (less all deductions allowed by the section in all tax years before the current one).

Clearly there is a difference between the 1994 provision and that appearing in the 2004 and 2007 acts. It seems to us that this is an unintended consequence, and kindly request that you record this in your 'log'.

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 1994 DN 3(3) (b)
Status Finalised
Outcome
The Panel hs concluded and agree there is an unintended legislative change that arises in respect of section DU 12(3)(b).
 
The Income Tax Acts 2004 and 2007 are to be amended retrospectively.

Back

 
Home | Contact Us | Background | Issues Log | Submission Form | Panel Statement | Maintenance Items Log |
www.govt.nz
Potential for ULC Background Contact Us Home