Contacts

 Background

 Panel Statement

 Potential for Unintended  Legislative Changes
  

 Overview of Process

 Submitting Issues

 Panel Process

 Analysis

 Content/form of  submissions

 Outcomes and  Communication

 Penalties and Interest

 Disputes and Rulings  Processes

 


www.rewriteadvisory.govt.nz

Home Issues Log Submission Form FYI Issues Log
 

  The Issues Log






















 
Issue: IC 3(3), IG 1(5)(a)(ii)

Submission Number 123
Submitter Staples Rodway Limited

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 2007

IC 3(3)

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 2004

IG 1(5)(a)(ii)

Date Received

6/10/09
Description of issue

It appears that in the ITA 2007 the test measuring common voting interests may have been modified from the test under the ITA 2004.   

Your interpretation under the new Act 2007: Under section IC 3(3) of the ITA 2007, if the percentage interests in the companies differ, the percentage that is counted is the lowest percentage voting interest in each of the companies for the period.

Under the ITA 2004, section IG 1(5)(a)(ii), the corresponding test states that the lowest of the percentage voting interests of the person in each of the companies at that time is measured, if those percentages differ as between the companies.

The ITA 2007 test appears to be more akin to a continuity test requiring measurement of the lowest shareholding to be taken over the entire continuity period.  Instead, section IG 1(5)(ii) of the ITA 2004 made it clear that the test was applied as at a single point in time.

Section / Provision Income Tax Act 1994  
Status Finalised
Outcome The Panel's concludes there is an unintended legislative change arises in respect of section IC 3(3) of the Income Tax Act 2007 and the Income Tax Act 2007 be amended retrospectively.

Back

 
Home | ULC Issues Log | ULC Submission Form | Remedial Issues Log | Remedial Issues Submission Form | Maintenance Items Log
www.govt.nz
Potential for ULC Background Contact Us Home